Darnell McCauley has been charged with stabbing his brother during an argument at a residence in Neenah. (Photo courtesy Winnebago County Sheriff's Office)
OSHKOSH, WI (WTAQ-WLUK) – Darnell McCauley was sentenced Thursday to four years in prison for stabbing his brother 18 times.
McCauley, 27, was previously convicted of aggravated battery and second-degree recklessly endangering safety for the Dec. 18, 2023, incident at a residence on Marathon Avenue in Neenah.
He was also placed on extended supervision for six years by Judge Daniel Bissett, court records show.
A woman at the home told police McCauley had made multiple comments about killing his brother and her. At one point, an argument about a cigar escalated. She thought it had defused, but moments later saw McCauley stabbing his brother, the complaint states.
The victim was taken to the hospital for treatment of wounds to his arm, neck, head, shoulder and back — with a total of least 18 different injuries, including a punctured lung.
The victim told police “that the defendant was acting up while drinking and he is the one who started things and (the victim) was just trying to keep the defendant from acting up,” the complaint says.
However, McCauley told police his brother was the one who had the knife, and he was acting in self-defense.
“The defendant stated that they were all drinking and smoking crack before the incident. The defendant stated that they had been fighting because (his brother) and (the woman) use him. The defendant stated that he cooks and cleans for them and he pays rent and they continue to use him. The defendant stated that he got irritated and his tolerance is low,” the complaint states.
The complaint also notes a Nov. 26 incident where McCauley went to the Neenah Police Dept. asking to be arrested because he was upset and planned to kill his brother. Crisis counselors were contacted at that time.
Comments